South Africa after 30 years of democracy: Land claims and transitional justice in the spotlight
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.38140/ijss-2024.vol4.23Keywords:
Inequalities, land, poverty, transformative justice, transitional justiceAbstract
Transitional justice is a universal strategy employed worldwide to secure peace and avoid warfare when an authoritarian regime is succeeded by democratic rule. The short duration of the transitional process and the lesser priority placed on social justice have impacted rural poverty, unresolved land reforms, ideological differences, and inequalities. This literature review explores the disadvantages of transitional justice and government policies regarding land reforms. It traces the causes of conflicts surrounding land that have affected rural poverty by examining the roles played by transitional justice, land acts, and government policies over the past 30 years. The research is underpinned by the conflict theory of Karl Marx and Engels, which does not commit to socialism or capitalism while highlighting the conflict between the wealthy and the poor. The literature reveals that South Africa is experiencing conflicts rooted in socio-economic challenges, political differences, inequalities, and poverty due to unresolved land issues. Based on the findings, the paper concludes that transitional justice has adopted a neo-liberal angle that compromises the rights of Black individuals. The implication is that transformative justice is needed to represent the voices of the people, address inequalities, and enable access to land as a necessity for food security and residential purposes.
References
African National Congress. (1994). The reconstruction and development programme: A policy framework, Johannesburg. Umyanyano Publication.
Akinola, A. O. (2019). Farm conflicts and the South African unresolved land question. Ubuntu: Journal of Conflict and Social Transformation, 8(2), 75-92. https://hdl.handle.net/10520/EJC-1a70ebf228
Baines, E. (2010). Spirits and social reconstruction after mass violence: Rethinking transitional justice. African affairs, 109(436), 409–430. https://doi.org/10.1093/afraf/adq023
Basti, P. (2013). The base and the Superstructure. International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention, 2(3), 75–77.
Bitzer, V., Obi, A., & Ndou, P. (2016). Keeping up with rising quality demands? New institutional arrangements, upgrading and market access in the South African citrus industry. In J. Bijman & V. Bitzer (Eds.), Quality and innovation in food chains (pp. 141–160). Wageningen Academic.
Bowsher, J. (2020). The South African TRC as neoliberal reconciliation: Victim subjectivities and the synchronisation of effects. Social & Legal Studies, 29(1), 41–64. https://doi.org/10.1177/0964663918822139
Cibane, S. (2015). South Africa's Negotiated Settlement: Did Nelson Mandela Sell the Rainbow Nation Cheap? Available at SSRN 2603401.
Cudd, A. E. (2015). Is capitalism good for women? Journal of Business Ethics, 127, 761–770. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-014-2185-9
D’Amato, P. (1999). Marxism and Oppression. International Socialist Review, 9(1999), 29–37.
Davids, I., & Theron, F. (2016). Development, the state and civil society in South Africa. Van Schaik.
de Greiff, P. (2011). Transitional justice, security, and development: Security and justice thematic paper. World Development Report 2011.
Department of Rural Development and Land Reform. (2017). Land Audit Report. Phase II: Private land ownership by race, gender, and nationality. Department of Rural Development and Land Reform, South Africa.
Dlamini, S. (2014). Taking land reform seriously: From willing seller-willing buyer to expropriation. https://open.uct.ac.za/server/api/core/bitstreams/df273ceb-dd4e-43e5-aedd-a4bcd2802689/content
Dugard, J. (2019). Unpacking Section 25: What, if any, are the legal barriers to transformative land reform? Constitutional Court Review, 9(1), 135–160. https://doi.org/10.2989/CCR.2019.0006
Edara, D. (2016). Biography of a Blunder: Base and Superstructure in Marx and Later. Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Erasmus, Z., & Harry, G. (2017). The South African error: Restorative justice sans social recompense. Rethinking Reconciliation, Evidence from South Africa, 337-352.
Evans, M. (2016). Structural violence, socioeconomic rights, and transformative justice. Journal of Human Rights, 15(1), 1–20. https://doi.org/10.1080/14754835.2015.1032223
Evans, M. (2019). Addressing historical wrongs in post-transition South Africa: What role for transformative justice? In Transitional and Transformative Justice (pp. 36–53). Routledge.
Gready, P. (2010). The era of transitional justice: The aftermath of the truth and reconciliation commission in South Africa and beyond. Routledge.
Gready, P., & Robins, S. (2014). From transitional to transformative justice: A new agenda for practice. International Journal of Transitional Justice, 8(3), 339–361. https://doi.org/10.1093/ijtj/iju013
Harman, C. (1986). Base and superstructure. International Socialism, 2(32), 3–44.
Heywood, M. (2019).“South Africa’s journey from socialism to human rights: The true confessions of an errant socialist.” Journal of Human Rights Practice, 11(2), 305–323.
Johnson, R. W. (2017). How long will South Africa survive? The crisis continues. United Kingdom: Jonathan Ball Publishers
Kersting, N. (2010). Direct democracy in constitutional processes: The South African plebiscite of 1992. Politikon, 37(2-3), 207-222. https://doi.org/10.1080/02589346.2010.522330
Khunou, S. F. (2016). The Legal Crisis of Land Restitution in South Africa: A Critical Analysis. RiA Recht in Afrika| Law in Africa| Droit en Afrique, 18(2), 153-180.
Kirsten, J., & Vink, N. (2019). Unravelling the complexities of land reform in South Africa. Daily Maverick, 29.
Lambourne, W. (2009). Transitional justice and peacebuilding after mass violence. International journal of transitional justice, 3(1), 28-48.
Land Audit Report. (2017). Land Audit Report. Phase II: Private land ownership by race, gender, and nationality. Department of Rural Development and Land Reform. Retrieved March 6, 2024.
Laplante, L. J. (2009). Outlawing amnesty: The return of criminal justice in transitional justice schemes. Virginia Journal of International Law, 49, 08-26.
Leon, P. (2018). Land expropriation without compensation: SA risks breaching international law and being massively sued. BizNews, Johannesburg, July, 25.
Mathiba, G. (2021). Corruption in land administration and governance: A hurdle to transitional justice in post-apartheid South Africa? Obiter, 42(3), 561–579. https://hdl.handle.net/10520/ejc-obiter_v42_n3_a7
Marx, K., & Engels, F. (2016). Manifesto of the communist party. In Social Theory Re-Wired (pp. 136-144). Routledge.
Mboti, N. (2023). Apartheid Studies: A Manifesto. Africa World Press
McEvoy, K., & McConnachie, K. (2013). Victims and transitional justice: Voice, agency and blame. Social & Legal Studies, 22(4), 489–513. https://doi.org/10.1177/0964663913499062
Megbowon, E. T. (2018). Multidimensional poverty analysis of urban and rural households in South Africa. Studia Universitatis Babes Bolyai-Oeconomica, 63(1), 3-19.
Millar, G., & Lecy, J. (2016). Disciplinary divides in post-conflict justice and peace: Tracking if and how we share ideas. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding, 10(3), 302–320. https://doi.org/10.1080/17502977.2016.1199481
Miller, Z. (2020). Embedded ambivalence: Ungoverning global justice. Transnational Legal Theory, 11(3), 353–381. https://doi.org/10.1080/20414005.2020.1830571
Modise, L., & Mtshiselwa, N. (2013). The Natives Land Act of 1913 engineered the poverty of black South Africans: A historico-ecclesiastical perspective. Studia Historiae Ecclesiasticae, 39(2), 359-378.
Moleah, A. T. (1993). South Africa: colonialism, apartheid and African dispossession. Disa Press.
Mosala, S. J., Venter, J. C. M., & Bain, E. G. (2017). South Africa's economic transformation since 1994: What influence has the National Democratic Revolution (NDR) had? The Review of Black Political Economy, 44(3-4), 327-340. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12114-017-9260-2
Moyo, K. (2015). Mimicry, transitional justice and the land question in racially divided former settler colonies. International Journal of Transitional Justice, 9(1), 70–89. https://doi.org/10.1093/ijtj/iju026
Mubecua, M., & Mlambo, V. H. (2021). The Expropriation of Land Without Compensation in South Africa: A Strategy for Alleviating or Worsening Poverty? The new political economy of land reform in South Africa, 55-77. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-51129-6_4
Mudau, J., Mukonza, R. M., & Ntshangase, B. A. (2018). A comparative overview of land reform experiences in Zimbabwe, Namibia and South Africa: a lesson that South Africa can learn from. Journal of Public Administration, 53(2-1), 580-601.
Mudau, J. (2021). Land expropriation without compensation in a former settler colony: A polemic discourse. African Renaissance, 18(3), 163–183. https://doi.org/10.31920/2516-5305/2021/18n3a8
Mukhudwana, R. F. (2021). Conspicuous and performative Blackness as decolonial political branding against the myth of the post-colonial society: A case of the EFF. In Decolonising Political Communication in Africa (pp. 26-44). Routledge.
Munyao, M. (2021). ‘New wine, old wineskins’: a comparative study of interfaith engagement and transitional justice in Kenya and South Africa. Journal of the British Academy, 9(s2), 103–125. https://doi.org/10.5871/jba/009s2.103
Ngcukaitobi, T. (2021). Land matters: South Africa’s failed land reforms and the road ahead. Penguin Books.
Omodan, B. I. (2024a). Redefining university infrastructure for the 21st century: An interplay between physical assets and digital evolution. Journal of Infrastructure, Policy and Development, 8(4), 3468. https://doi.org/10.24294/jipd.v8i4.3468
Omodan, B. I. (2024b). Decolonising student services: Implications for conflict management in higher education. Routledge Open Research, 3, 21. https://doi.org/10.12688/routledgeopenres.18311.1
Oxford, T. (2018). The complex insecurity of hunger in South Africa. Mail & Guardian.
Pienaar, J. M. (2015). Land reform embedded in the constitution: Legal contextualisation. Scriptura: Journal for Contextual Hermeneutics in Southern Africa, 114(1), 1-20.
Pradier, A., Rubin, M., & van der Merwe, H. (2018). Between transitional justice and politics: Reparations in South Africa. South African Journal of International Affairs, 25(3), 301-321.
Plaatje, S. T. (1995). Native life in South Africa. Ravan.
Piotrowski, A. (2019). Colonialism, apartheid, and democracy: South Africa's historical implications on the land reform debate. Journal of Interdisciplinary Undergraduate Research, 11(1), 4-11.
Resane, K. T. (2019). The role of the church in the land debate.’ Scriptura, 118(1), 1–9.
Resane, K. T. (2023). Theology of Land: Reflections and Dialogue from a South African Socio-Political Perspective. Scriptura, 122(1), 1-15. http://dx.doi.org/10.7833/122-1-2094
Sebola, M. P. (2022). “Land Expropriation without Compensation:” Populist Political Charade and Electioneering Slogan in South Africa’s 2019 National Elections. African Journal of Development Studies, 12(1), 297.
Sharp, D. N. (2014). Addressing dilemmas of the global and the local in transitional justice. Emory International Law Review, 29, 71.
Stahn, C. (2020). Confronting colonial amnesia: Towards new relational engagement with colonial injustice and cultural colonial objects. Journal of International Criminal Justice, 18(4), 793–824. https://doi.org/10.1093/jicj/mqaa052
Statistics South Africa (2015). General Household Survey 2014. Statistics South Africa. Statistics South Africa, Pretoria, 0001.
Suttner, R. (1985). The Freedom Charter: The People's Charter in the 1980s. Crime and Social Justice, (24), 72-95.
Tedman, G. (2010). Base, Superstructure, Aesthetic Level: further notes on a theory. New Proposals: Journal of Marxism and Interdisciplinary Inquiry, 4(1), 23-28
Turner, C. (2016). Violence, law and the impossibility of transitional justice. Routledge.
Xaba, M. B. (2021). South African land question and the dilemma of land expropriation without compensation: A critical examination. In A. O. Akinola, I. Kaseeram, & N. N. Jili (Eds.), The new political economy of land reform in South Africa (pp. 73–89). Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-51129-6_5
Xaba, M. B., & Akinola, A. O. (2023). A reflection on the nexus between South African land reform struggles and the unresolved national question. International Journal of African Renaissance Studies, 18(1), 136-155. https://doi.org/10.1080/18186874.2022.2095922
Yende, N. E. (2021). The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) as a “super-sub” in the South African Parliament: Fostering Accountability in Organised Disruptive Chaos. African Journal of Development Studies, 11(4), 53. https://doi.org/10.31920/2634-3649/2021/v11n4a3
Yeni, S. (2018). Land is More than Farming: Former labour tenants’ views on land expropriation without compensation. Focus, 1, 23.
Yu, D. (2017). The comparability of the statistics South Africa October household surveys and labour force surveys. Stellenbosch Economic Working Papers: 17/07.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Copyright (c) 2024 Pulane Adelaide Molomo, Bekithemba Dube
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
