Wysgerige kanttekeninge by H.J. van Eikema Hommes se regsbeginsel-teorie
Philosophical notes to H.J. van Eikema Hommes’ theory of legal princples
Herman Dooyeweerd’s transcendental critique of theoretical thought paved the way for gaining a new understanding of the dynamic meaningstructure of the juridical aspect within the coherence of man’s experiential world. The transcendental understanding of the juridical aspect makes it possible to demonstrate that the structural configuration of this aspect can never be grasped in a static conceptual formula but that it can be approximated only by the dynamic method of successive analysis of its structural elements, guided by a theoretical idea of law. The fundamental concept of law turns out to be a transcendental empirical method of inquiry into the fundamental structure of the juridical aspect. In addition to these ‘retrocipatory’ analogies there are also “‘anticipatory’ analogies in the modal structure of the juridical aspect. These anticipatory analogous moments only reveal themselves when legal life is being disclosed in the direction of legal-ethical principles, thereby disclosing, deepening and refining legal life in different legal systems”. In addition to the concept of law and the idea of law, Hommes distinguishes the respective modal and typical jural principles, and the accompanying constitutive and regulative principles in man’s horizon of legal experience. Hommes’ theory of legal principles enables him to steer clear of the false dilemma posed by the conflicting views of natural law theory and legal positivism respectively. Furthermore his theory of legal principles makes a valuable contribution to the ongoing debate about ideology critique in the science of law.
In Terms of the provisions in the Copyright Act, 98 of 1987, as amended, the copyright of author(s) in regard to articles submitted to and published in the Journal for Christian Scholarship is protected. The Vereniging vir Christelike Hoër Onderwys (VCHO) posesses the vested rights (copyright) in regard to published issues of the journal.
Die outeursreg (kopiereg) van outers ten opsigte van voorgelegde artikels aan en gepubliseerde artikels in die Tydskrif vir Christelike Wetenskap word beskerm, ingevolge die bepalings van die Wet op Outeursreg, 98 van 1987, soos gewysig. Die Vereniging vir Christelike Hoër Onderwys (VCHO) beskik oor die gevestigde regte (outeursreg) ten opsigte van gepubliseerde uitgawes van die tydskrif.